Joyce Doyle seeks acceptance from her successful family and suffers workplace betrayal. After reporting abusive office chat, she retreats to a remote Devon cottage, finds a dead man, loses her phone during a storm, and faces a mounting, claustrophobic mystery.
Plot setup: workplace humiliation pushes protagonist to a remote Devon cottage where a storm cuts her off and a dead body appears.
Character critique: Joyce is described as highly educated yet makes implausible decisions that frustrated the reviewer.
Joyce Doyle has spent her life trying to match her family's expectations. Despite multiple university degrees, she works in a marketing firm to please her father. At work she's isolated, then briefly flattered by a handsome colleague, Ben, who reveals his interest was part of a bet. That humiliation is followed by discovery of racist and bullying messages in an office chat group. Joyce reports the chat, which leads to the suspension of three employees and exposes her as the whistle‑blower.
Forced to take time off, Joyce withdraws to her parents' off‑season holiday cottage in rural Devon. The remote setting and a violent storm that severs communications create the confined, tense atmosphere central to the novel. Joyce finds a man's body in the river outside the cottage and, in the chaos of the storm and the river's current, loses her cell phone. The isolation, lost contact, and the presence of a dead body drive the narrative into thriller mode.
Fictionophile calls The Outsider an "on the edge of your seat" thriller that will keep readers turning pages late into the night. The review highlights core thriller elements present in the book: a remote setting, a violent storm, suspenseful pacing, and multiple plot twists. The reviewer enjoyed the entertainment value but felt the book leaned heavily on familiar thriller formulas.
The main criticism centers on Joyce's characterization. Although presented as an intelligent woman with several degrees, the reviewer felt Joyce repeatedly makes poor or disastrous decisions that undermine believability. That gap between the protagonist's stated intelligence and her actions was a source of frustration for the reviewer.
The review frames The Outsider as a short, brisk thriller that delivers familiar genre beats and twists. It offers a suspenseful, easy read for fans of tidy, page-turning psychological suspense, while raising questions about character plausibility for readers who prioritize realistic decision‑making by protagonists.
Birdie Keller has no ‘blood relations’. She did once have a mother and a much-loved sister, but tragically, her half-sister Providence was murdered… In the 1970s, Providence’s body was found in a rape field, beneath a scarecrow the locals called … Continue reading →
This story begins at an exclusive London boarding school with best friends Freya and Josephine who are both seventeen years old. It would seem everything is going their way, and the world is their oyster until… they decide to celebrate … Continue reading →
Every once in a while, it’s good to read outside of your comfort zone. Personally speaking, I have always been most interested in reading towards the more hard-boiled end of the crime fiction spectrum, for example the gritty realism of Don Winslow’s Cartel series, or... The post Lie To Me by DS Butler first appeared on
It’s 1904, and being a detective – let alone an occult detective – is no profession for a woman. But that won’t stop Evie Winstanley. When her father, a collector of occult books, dies in strange circumstances, Evie is determined to investigate. Her only lead: a cryptic mention of the ‘Circle of Shadows.’ From a […]
Irish Goodbye – when you leave without saying goodbye in order to avoid emotional displays and/or to avoid disturbing others. This debut novel was on many ‘Best of 2025’ lists by my fellow bookbloggers, so I was extra keen to … Continue reading →
Our protagonist, Jude Gray, is a young, childless widow who now runs her large sheep farm with the help of Noah, her shepherd, and her loyal dogs, Pip and Archie – with memories of her late husband never far from … Continue reading →
Loading more related stories...
Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.