Archived PI Movie Review: The Brasher Doubloon (1947)

# Overview

THE BRASHER DOUBLOON (1947) is a film adaptation of Raymond Chandler's novel The High Window. The movie stars George Montgomery as private eye Philip Marlowe and features Nancy Guild, Conrad Janis, Florence Bates, Roy Roberts, and Marvin Miller. John Brahm directed the picture.

# What the review says

# Strengths highlighted

The strongest elements in the review are atmosphere and casting. The film's characters and the way the Southern California winds and setting are filmed are called "just right." Nancy Guild receives specific praise for projecting a naive, innocent allure that fits the role. The reviewer suggests these elements almost make The Brasher Doubloon the ideal private-eye movie.

# Weaknesses noted

The reviewer repeatedly says the main weakness is the plot's slipperiness. Despite the film's near-perfect feeling in mood and character, the reviewer confesses they would call it perfect only if they understood the plot a little more. That lack of narrative clarity is the central reservation.

# Adaptation context

The review and ensuing comments on the reprint point out that Chandler's material has been adapted in different ways. Earlier films repurposed Chandler's plots by changing Marlowe into other detectives—Time to Kill made the story about Michael Shayne (Lloyd Nolan), and The Falcon Takes Over reimagined elements with The Falcon (George Sanders). That history invites side-by-side comparison when judging how faithful or effective a particular adaptation is.

# Reader reactions included with the reprint

Commenters on the reprinted entry add perspective rather than contradicting the review. One commenter doesn't remember the film well and plans to rewatch it. Another recalls not being fond of the lead actor's portrayal but still considering the novel and film underrated. A few notes reflect curiosity about Montgomery's suitability as Marlowe and an appreciation for how the setting contributes to the film's feel.

# Practical takeaway for a reader

If you want a Marlowe picture driven by mood, setting, and performances, this review recommends giving The Brasher Doubloon a look. If you prioritize tightly plotted mysteries where every twist is transparent on first viewing, expect some narrative slipperiness. The film is also worth watching for comparative study of how Chandler's work has been adapted and recast in different eras.

# Closing note

The reprinted review is candid about liking the film's sensory elements while being uncertain about its story mechanics. That combination makes this title interesting for viewers drawn to classic noir atmosphere and for those who want to compare film adaptations of Chandler's novel to other versions.