Scitechdaily iconScitechdailySep 20, 2026 ~5 min source read

Ship Observations Reveal Why Southern Ocean Cloud Errors Break Climate Models

Measurements from an Antarctic research voyage show that climate models can misjudge cloud phase and atmospheric temperature, causing models with too many low clouds to still underpredict heat reaching the ocean surface.

A Cloudy Climate Mystery Over Antarctica Has Scientists Rethinking Their Models

Share this story

Send the public story page.

Useful takeaways from this story.

Reanalyses and a climate model agree on broad cloud patterns but overcount low clouds compared with ship observations.

All datasets underestimated downward longwave radiation because simulated clouds contained too much ice and the atmosphere was too cold.

Increasing aerosol concentrations in the model raised low-cloud frequency but had little effect on surface heat, so fixing cloud amount alone won’t close the radiation gap.

The useful part

New ship-based observations suggest that errors in cloud composition and atmospheric temperature, not simply cloud abundance, may be driving the mismatch and limiting climate predictions. Shutterstock Researchers compare observations with leading climate models to identify errors and help improve future climate predictions. Some simulations put too many low clouds over the Southern Ocean, yet still underestimate how much heat reaches the surface below.

How it works

  • Clouds influence the climate by controlling how much sunlight reaches Earth and by absorbing and emitting heat.
  • ERA5 and MERRA-2, however, consistently produced low clouds more often than the observations showed.
  • ERA5 and MERRA-2 contained higher concentrations than the ship observed, prompting the researchers to test increased Southern Hemisphere aerosol emissions in CAM-ATRAS.
  • The researchers call for expanded observations across the Southern Ocean and Antarctica, including temperature measurements to help address the cold bias.
  • Instead of being presented as trustworthy simulations of how the dynamic system works, they are presented as numeric hypotheses that are compared to other models and actual measurements.

What to take from it

Assistant Professor Kazutoshi Sato notes, "Because observations over Antarctica remain sparse, numerical models still contain substantial uncertainties in their representation of the Antarctic atmosphere. When that happens with aerodynamic models, a test pilot's life is put at risk. Over the Southern Ocean, a region central to regulating Earth's climate, errors in either process can distort weather forecasts and projections of future warming.

Example or evidence

  • Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email Reddit Related Articles Ozone Pollution Has Increased in Antarctica – From Both Natural and Human Sources Climate Science Surprise:
  • It is possible to build a model that is right sometimes, but fails at other critical times that weren't taken into consideration.
  • In December 2022 and March 2023, the ship's instruments continuously recorded cloud properties, atmospheric temperature and humidity, radiation at the surface, and concentrations of aerosols, tiny airborne...
  • The team compared these observations with ERA5 and MERRA-2, two widely used atmospheric reanalysis datasets that combine observations with numerical models to reconstruct atmospheric conditions, and with...

Details worth keeping

The findings were published in Geophysical Research Letters. All three broadly reproduced cloud patterns over the Southern Ocean. Comparing real-world observations with climate models reveals key sources of uncertainty in Southern Ocean cloud simulations.

Related coverage

  • Columbia: John "not Towering Inferno" Williams points to this new research article by Valentin Portmann et al., which states: Climate models show considerable discrepancies in their future projections around the...
  • Science Daily: The Arctic sea ice melt season is roughly 40 days longer than it was in 1979, yet its rapid expansion unexpectedly leveled off around 2010.
  • Science Daily: East Antarctica gained an astonishing 695 billion tons of ice between 2021 and 2023, temporarily slowing Antarctica's long-term decline.
  • Phys: Where is Earth's center of mass?

More context around this story.

Earth's center of mass drifts less than we thought
Phys iconPhysSep 21, 2026

Earth's center of mass drifts less than we thought

Where is Earth's center of mass? The answer seems trivially obvious. It's right in the middle of the planet. Ah, but that kind of thinking won't get you a paper in the Geophysical Journal International. It's also not a trivial question. Knowing Earth's center of mass to within millimeters reveals some interesting facts

Loading more related stories...

Keep reading in the app

Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.

Open in app