Catholicexchange iconCatholicexchangeSep 23, 2026 ~7 min source read

Padre Pio and the Popes: how four pontificates treated a controversial stigmatist

A concise account of how Padre Pio’s relationship with successive popes ranged from suspicion and sanctions to support and restored freedom, with concrete events and decisions that shaped his ministry.

Padre Pio and the Popes: A Dance of Love and Hate

Share this story

Send the public story page.

Useful takeaways from this story.

Pope Pius XI, influenced by Fr. Agostino Gemelli, suspected Padre Pio of fraud and ordered heavy restrictions, including a two-year confinement in his friary.

Pope Pius XII became an advocate for Padre Pio, permitted broad pastoral activity, granted a dispensation to manage hospital funds, and praised his ministry.

Pope Paul VI consulted Padre Pio near the end of the friar’s life, lifted prior sanctions, and allowed him to minister openly until his death on September 23, 1968.

The useful part

History & Art During the wild 1920s, the pope at the time, Pope Pius XI, had been influenced by his best friend, Fr. Pio's ulterior motive was to be reverenced as a flesh portrait of the crucified Christ. Gemelli even denounced Pio as "a psychopath" who fooled gullible people that the wounds had been given to him by Jesus.

How it works

  • His Holiness did, however, order that Pio be imprisoned in his friary for two years, and even though he rescinded this order in 1933, he never trusted the stigmatist whom he suspected of taking advantage of...
  • Pio became like an angel and flew through the sky to prevent bombing raids, and he befriended multitudes of American servicemen, who in turn went back to America and spread the word about the wonderworking...
  • In the years after, Paul VI continued to follow the last direction Pio gave him when he didn't give the green light to contraception.
  • Mary worked as a journalist in London for a decade, has blogged at Mary's Blog for 17 years, and spent 8 years working on Padre Pio and You.
  • Name Description Duration Cookie Preferences This cookie is used to store the user's cookie consent preferences.

What to take from it

Contact Us Tap into The Wellspring daily Spiritual direction, encouragement, and edification in your inbox every weekday. This refuted the false notion that abounded during Pius XI's time that the poor were seen as "easy prey." Pius XII is perhaps best known as being the wartime pope during the hellscape of World War II, when whole cities were bombed and over 153,000 Italian civilians perished. Pius XI was ready to strip Pio of all his faculties and suspend the 38-year-old who was being hailed as the "Second St.

Example or evidence

  • By Derek Rotty Fulton Sheen's Antidotes for Anxiety Leave a Review Leave a Review Your Details create a review I agree that my review may be published publicly.
  • Name Description Duration cookiePreferences Registers cookie preferences of a user 2 years td Registers statistical data on users' behaviour on the website.
  • Gemelli was a medical doctor and a psychologist who claimed that Pio did not have the genuine stigmata and that the carmine piercings on Pio's hands and feet were self-inflicted by Pio's own mind—a...
  • It was Padre Pio bilocating to the hallowed halls so he could plead his case personally.

Details worth keeping

Padre Pio and the Popes: A Dance of Love and Hate. Agostino Gemelli, to regard Padre Pio as a malevolent villain. Pio knelt before the pope, kissed his feet, and begged, "Your Holiness, for the good of the Church, do not permit this to occur." Pio kissed Pius's feet again and promptly disappeared.

Related coverage

  • Catholicexchange: "Send me your angel," was a common direction St.
  • Lifesitenews: An Italian priest has been excommunicated for schism, but he rejects the charge.
  • Lifesitenews: Fr. Leonardo Maria Pompei tells LifeSiteNews how upholding traditional Catholic teaching through online preaching led to his suspension, a schism charge, and now excommunication.

More context around this story.

Padre Pio and the Power of Guardian Angels
Catholicexchange iconCatholicexchangeSep 25, 2026

Padre Pio and the Power of Guardian Angels

“Send me your angel,” was a common direction St. Pio of Pietrelcina would give his spiritual children and the penitents who sought his guidance. For Padre Pio, this was not merely a vague, sentimental idea. He believed in and relied on angels throughout his ministry and had the gift of communicating with them. This mir

Bd Journal iconBd JournalSep 20, 2026

সাতকানিয়ায় টà§à¦°à§‡à¦¨à§‡à¦° ধাকà§à¦•ায় নিহত ২

চটà§à¦Ÿà¦—à§à¦°à¦¾à¦®à§‡à¦° সাতকানিয়ায় টà§à¦°à§‡à¦¨à§‡à¦° ধাকà§à¦•ায় দà§à¦‡ অটো রিকশা আরোহীর পà§à¦°à¦¾à¦£ গেছে। রোববার উপজেলার কালিয়াইশ ইউনিয়নের পূরà§à¦¬ কাটগড় রেà¦

Loading more related stories...

Keep reading in the app

Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.

Open in app