# Overview
Moshe, a Jewish cobbler who becomes entangled in a world of dream, ambition, and corruption. Moshe operates as what the review calls the hand of Hashem, opposing a rasha who abuses spiritual connections and gifts for personal gain. Though this is the second book in a series, the review says the volume stands alone by providing Moshe's backstory and past uses by Hashem.
# Characters and themes
Moshe is presented as a steady, older protagonist who balances ordinary cobbler work with metaphysical responsibilities. The rasha is the moral antagonist, pursuing power and pleasure regardless of ethics or harm. Many main characters are older men versed in Kabbalah, either through necessity or interest, while younger figures—such as the mob boss's daughter and the rasha's son—add romantic and criminal subplots.
Women have notable, concrete roles: one serves as a mole inside the rasha's son's office and another trains Moshe to move through the dream world. The review highlights thematic concerns with politics, spirituality, and individual place in the world, largely explored through dialogue and reflection rather than action.
# Worldbuilding and setting
# Strengths
- The metaphysical system is described as unique, consistent, and grounded in specific mystical teachings.
- The book balances realism (Moshe's everyday work, political texture) with fantasy elements, creating a relaxed, intriguing tone.
- Women are given meaningful agency in the conflict, expanding the cast beyond expected archetypes.
- The narrative tone includes humor and empathy, helping the book feel accessible beyond readers already familiar with Jewish mysticism.
# Weaknesses
- Pacing can be slow, with extended stretches of dialogue and repeated storytelling that create a sense of redundancy.
- Much of the thematic exploration occurs through discussion rather than active scenes, which may make parts of the book feel talk-heavy.
# Who will likely enjoy this book
Readers who prefer historically flavored fantasy, metaphysical systems tied to real mystical traditions, and character-driven stories with political and spiritual debates will find this appealing. Those wanting fast-paced action or terse plotting may find the tempo and repetition frustrating.
# Bottom line
One offers a distinctive, Kabbalah-grounded metaphysical fantasy with a grounded protagonist and a cast that includes both seasoned mystics and criminal figures. It reads as a standalone second volume, delivering atmosphere and consistent worldbuilding while asking readers to accept a contemplative, sometimes repetitive storytelling approach.