Early data and team examples show name‑image‑likeness deals plus unrestricted transfer movement have made outcomes less predictable at the top level rather than concentrating power among a few programs.
Through seven weeks of the 2025 season, AP Top 10 teams had lost 14 games, tying the most in a decade and indicating greater unpredictability.
Coaches point to the transfer portal as the initial disruptor, with NIL amplifying roster turnover in both directions — helping bluebloods and smaller programs alike.
The increased parity has limits, and the article notes the gap hasn’t closed completely but is not moving in the direction many initially feared.
# What changed When players gained the right to move freely through the transfer portal and to earn money via NIL, many expected the top programs to get stronger and the sport to become more predictable. The early results tell a different story. Through the first seven weeks of the 2025 season, AP Top 10 teams had lost 14 games, a mark tied for the most in the past decade. That statistic points to more volatility at the sport's highest level, not less.
# How the portal and NIL interact
# Concrete examples: Indiana and SMU Indiana: The Hoosiers provide a clear before‑and‑after example. The program had been notable for historically high loss totals, then turned into an 11‑2 team in 2024 and reached its first College Football Playoff. That run culminated in a 16‑0 national championship season in 2025. Much of that turnaround relied on transfer additions that delivered immediate, high‑impact contributions rather than waiting multiple recruiting classes for development.
SMU: Southern Methodist University pursued a similar strategy at scale. Over three seasons the program brought in 56 transfers. Those additions helped produce two seasons with nine or more wins and a College Football Playoff appearance. SMU's model illustrates how a nontraditional power can use the portal to shortcut the multi‑year rebuilding path.
# What this means for competitive balance
# The limits of parity The article notes there are limits to this shift. The gap between the very best programs and the rest hasn't disappeared. Resources, coaching, institutional appeal, and recruiting infrastructure still matter. What has changed is the path to competitive relevance: programs can now assemble immediate contributors through the portal rather than relying solely on long recruiting cycles.
# Bottom line The early seasons after unrestricted transfers and NIL show increased turnover and competitive volatility at the top of college football. Rather than concentrating power, the new rules have produced rapid rebuilds and surprise contenders. The trend's durability and ultimate effect on long‑term competitive balance remain open questions, but the near‑term result is clearer: games and rankings are less predictable than many expected.
Ohio State’s 2024 transfer portal class was as good as it could possibly get. The Buckeyes brought in eight total guys, and five of them — Caleb Downs, Will Howard, Quinshon Judkins, Will Kacmarek and Seth McLaughlin — were high-impact players on a National Championship roster. A sixth was Julian Sayin, who is now in [
In today's era of college football, the transfer portal and NIL have become the focal points of offseason decision making for players. For schools that aren't swimming in NIL funds, retaining key players can sometimes become nearly impossible to do.
Back in the offseason, the Wisconsin Badgers went a different route in the transfer portal this year, using their increased pool of resources to target quantity, as they brought in over 30 transfers. That idealogy was best seen at wide receiver, where Wisconsin added Jaylon Domingeaux, Shamar Rigby, Malachi Coleman, an
BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (AP) - The Southeastern Conference has experienced a steady drop in the number of players from its own states who stay close to home to play in the conference since the dawn of the name, image and likeness era that turned college sports upside down, an Associated Press analysis of recruiting data has f
How revenue sharing, NIL money and the transfer portal are changing college basketball and making it harder for mid-majors to retain talent.
Each week, teams will be fighting for position in an effort to make the College Football Playoff. The teams will be ranked each week, but what matters most is who they have played and defeated already on the field. Here is College Football Playoff Preseason Bracketology: September 20. Note: This will be updated followi
Loading more related stories...
Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.