Episode 36 of Becoming Brigham explains why Brigham Young decided the Nauvoo temple work had to finish before departure, how the westward plan developed, and why most Saints followed a blunt leader into the West.
The idea of a western refuge had roots in earlier thinking—traced by Brett Dowdle to Joseph Smith in 1838 and reinforced by Brigham’s 1845 dream and Governor Thomas Ford’s warning about rising mob violence.
By late August 1846 Brigham framed the community’s two priorities: complete the temple ordinances and prepare to leave for the West.
Despite Brigham’s blunt, sometimes abrasive style, most Saints followed him to Utah and regarded him as a father-figure, a fact addressed as relevant to modern readers wrestling with difficult historical personalities.
This episode examines the tension between two urgent needs facing the Latter-day Saints in 1846: preserving lives by leaving an increasingly dangerous Illinois, and fulfilling a spiritual promise—the endowment promised to members through Nauvoo Temple ordinances. Brigham Young's solution was to complete the temple work before the exodus, a decision tied to a chain of earlier ideas about moving west.
Members resisted leaving without receiving the endowment. Brigham Young reported he received inspiration that the Saints should finish the Nauvoo temple before departing. That directive reframed the community's timeline: the temple had to be completed even while preparations began for migration.
Historian Brett Dowdle traces the concept of moving west to Joseph Smith as early as 1838. Brigham Young's own March 1845 dream of a mountain refuge reinforced the possibility of a western sanctuary. The political context accelerated plans: in April 1845 Governor Thomas Ford warned that mobs were increasing and Illinois could no longer guarantee the Saints' safety. Those developments combined spiritual prompting with pragmatic urgency.
The episode also addresses a longstanding puzzle: Brigham Young was often blunt and sometimes offensive, which created enemies and criticism. Despite that, the majority of Saints accepted his leadership and followed him to Utah, viewing him as a father-figure. The program explores why a leader with a sharp tongue could still command loyalty and how that dynamic matters for contemporary readers wrestling with Church history and leadership personalities.
The story combines spiritual claims, personal revelation reported by leaders, and a pressured political environment. It shows decision-making shaped by competing obligations—religious promises to members and immediate threats to safety. The episode focuses on how Brigham reconciled those obligations and how the community responded, rather than evaluating doctrinal claims beyond the historical record presented.
Brigham Young's decision to finish the Nauvoo temple before leaving was a strategic response to the Saints' unwillingness to migrate without the endowment and to escalating external threats. The episode uses that decision to explore leadership style, the roots of the westward plan, and why many Saints accepted a forceful leader in a crisis.
What did Brigham’s letter to the daughter he left behind reveal about how he saw himself as a substitute “father” to the Church? Why did the unfinished Nauvoo Temple become the sharpest dividing line between Brigham Young and Sidney Rigdon? Did Sidney Rigdon believe that the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles held the pries
How did Brigham Young ’s determination to never again be driven out of his home collide with Native peoples who were being pushed off the rivers and valleys of Utah? Why did a church that sent missionaries to Native Americans so early still end up building forts and fighting battles? Our hosts @BecomingBrigham visit an
Could the sentiments that “it’s cheaper to feed them than fight them” and “this is their home” exist at the same time in the same person who also called Native American life idle and refused to leave the lands in Utah? This episode explores Brigham Young’s Utah Indian policy after the first bloodshed. Historian John Pe
How did a stolen shirt turn a mission to the Native Americans into two decades of war? What would Utah history have looked like if the Saints and the Utes had treated sharing and consecration as a conversation instead of a one-way religious task? A relatively peaceful first two years in the Salt Lake Valley—which at th
Know the difference between Kingdom and Church. Church is not a place where one enters a building, come out of the building — and Church is over.
From Phillip Jensen – “Dear friends, The second half of 1 Corinthians 14 gives us great insight into the nature of church life. Having addressed the subject of prophecy and tongues in the light of love, Paul now discusses their use specifically in the church. We know from the first half of the chapter that […]
Loading more related stories...
Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.