Wrestlinginc iconWrestlingincSep 29, 2026 ~2 min source read

Nic Nemeth Asked Vince McMahon for Planned Injury Angles to Boost Return Reactions

Nemeth says his long run without injuries kept him on TV too often, so he proposed scripted injury storylines to create bigger returns, refresh characters, and give other wrestlers opportunities.

Nic Nemeth Says He Pitched Vince McMahon On Planned Injury Storylines In WWE

Share this story

Send the public story page.

Useful takeaways from this story.

He proposed planned injury angles as a way to refresh long-running characters, reduce fan fatigue, and create chances for other wrestlers to step into higher-card spots.

Nemeth used Cody Rhodes as an example of how a brief absence can allow multiple credible comeback directions—heel turn, redemption, or a tweener path.

The useful part

Nic Nemeth Says He Pitched Vince McMahon On Planned Injury Storylines In WWE Nic Nemeth Says He Pitched Vince McMahon On Planned Injury Storylines In WWE By Nishant Jayaram Sept. Speaking on " Busted Open," he explained how staying injury-free meant he missed out on those reactions. "I realized that, weirdly, I went practically injury-free for 19 and a half years.

How it works

  • "One, it gives other people a chance to step up into that middle or main event card.
  • "Going away helps whatever story you're trying to push, whether it's Cody being a tweener, Cody about to break and maybe turn on somebody, or Cody going, 'No, you know what?

Details worth keeping

29, 2026 11:00 am EST Bryan Steffy/Getty Images Add Wrestling Inc. I had to start begging Vince, saying, 'I need to go away for a few months, or else it's just you seeing me for 19 years, 52 weeks in a row.' So, I pitched an idea, not for me, but for everyone, to have injury angles where we create the big moments when someone comes back," he explained. Then it gives you a refresher when you come back.

Related coverage

  • Wrestlinginc: On "Busted Open", Nic Nemeth weighed in on Sunday's match between Bron Breakker and Oba Femi. He explained why it felt like something Vince McMahon would book.
  • Wrestlinginc: WWE star Nattie described the process of pitching ideas and characters to both Vince McMahon and Triple H.
  • Wrestlingheadlines: Perry Saturn believes his infamous Moppy storyline in WWE was designed as punishment for his unscripted attack on Mike Bell during a match in 2001.
  • Wrestlinginc: WWE legend John Cena has recalled the time Vince McMahon had plans for him to turn heel and the lengths he went to prepare for the role.
  • Wrestleview: I had an opportunity to speak exclusively via Casino.org US with current TNA World Heavyweight Champion and one…

More context around this story.

Loading more related stories...

Keep reading in the app

Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.

Open in app