Universetoday iconUniversetodaySep 29, 2026 ~5 min source read

New paper argues cumulative photosynthetic carbon, not age alone, may control how complex life gets on exoplanets

Researchers propose Net Primary Production (NPP) — total carbon fixed into biomass over time — as a measurable proxy for how far life could evolve on rocky exoplanets. Applying Earth benchmarks, many older worlds could still be “stuck in the slime age.”

Older Alien Worlds Might Still Be Stuck in the Slime Age

Share this story

Send the public story page.

Useful takeaways from this story.

Total photosynthetic carbon fixed over a planet’s history (cumulative NPP) can be a practical proxy for the amount of evolutionary opportunity life has had.

Using Earth as a benchmark, planets with low cumulative NPP may remain dominated by simple, single-celled life despite great age.

TRAPPIST-1e is likely a poor candidate for advanced life because of tidal locking, red-dwarf infrared output, and limited precipitation.

The useful part

Here's how we do it Artist's impression of the surface of a planet orbiting Proxima Centauri. Kornmesser There's an active debate in the astrobiology community of where to use our best telescopes to look for our best chance of seeing alien life. That debate has been going on for decades, and will continue for some time to come, but now there's another option up for consideration.

How it works

  • Christopher Doughty of Northern Arizona University talks about how the total amount of carbon a planet is able to bring into the service of biology is a good indication of how evolved life on it might be.
  • a measure of how much carbon photosynthetic organisms turn into organic matter every year.
  • They argue that the NPP of an exoplanet can serve as a rough "proxy" for how many "lives" have been lived on the planet.
  • After the Cambrian explosion, however, the amount of carbon capture skyrocketed, leading up to the advent of modern humans.
  • By the time our ancestors showed up, which the authors argue is a good point for the advent of "intelligence", the amount of carbon captured by biological processes had grown to 9.4x10^25 grams.

What to take from it

if a star has been around for longer than our Sun, its planets have likely been around longer than Earth. Therefore, they have had even longer than Earth has to develop complex, intelligent life. All these problems combine to make this particular exoplanet not a great candidate for advanced life.

Example or evidence

  • This has been a focal point of much astrobiological research, including an entire project to develop climate models.
  • Typically, astrobiologists have used the age of a planet's star as a proxy for its chances of harboring intelligent life.
  • In fact, not even all parts of the same planet are created equal in biological terms.
  • The tropics, where it is consistently warm, with abundant moisture and ample sunlight, churn out new species and evolutionary adaptations much faster than the frigid poles of our own planet.

Details worth keeping

Older Alien Worlds Might Still Be Stuck in the Slime Age. Universe Today Universe Today is 100% AD-FREE thanks to our patrons. A new paper in the International Journal of Astrobiology by Dr.

Related coverage

  • Scitechdaily: Even planets billions of years older than Earth may host only microbes if photosynthesis supplies too little energy.
  • Universetoday: Most of our experience with the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) has been focused on capturing radio signals that alien species have sent out, whether intentionally or unintentionally.
  • Phys: Most of our experience with the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) has focused on capturing radio signals that alien species have sent out, whether intentionally or unintentionally.
  • Scitechdaily: Researchers developed a model showing how lava-covered planets close to their stars can hold onto their atmospheres, which could help guide the search for life beyond our solar system.

More context around this story.

Loading more related stories...

Keep reading in the app

Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.

Open in app