Desiringgod iconDesiringgodSep 18, 2026 ~8 min source read

Preach Sermons, Not Commentaries

Greg Morse argues that many modern expository talks function as 'sermontaries'—detailed, multipoint commentaries that explain Scripture but fail to press truth into hearers’ hearts. He urges preachers to prioritize unity, persuasion, and a clear pastoral aim so sermons move minds into convictions and actions.

Preach Sermons, Not Commentaries

Share this story

Send the public story page.

Useful takeaways from this story.

Sermons should organize around a single, unifying idea with supporting divisions that build toward a climax rather than presenting equally weighted, scattershot points.

Preaching requires theological rigor plus deliberate strategic shape: persuasion, urgency, and targeted application for real spiritual change.

The useful part

Listen to Theology Refresh → Most people in the world have no experience of lasting joy in their lives. All of our resources exist to guide you toward everlasting joy in Jesus Christ. It is so hard and impregnable that it takes divine weapons and skilled soldiers to regularly invade it with the truth.

How it works

  • As I see it, though the sermontary and the sermon share similar aims, they differ in their means.
  • The lessons end where the section ends, and if time remains, a thought of how this applies is offered.
  • Listen to other sermons, try to reproduce their outlines, and analyze how they did.
  • Place for Structure Let's conclude by examining one of Spurgeon's sermon outlines, noticing beforehand how he felt about sermontaries.
  • Truth in Battle Array Hearing some preaching today gives me the same disorientation I have had watching my children play in the front yard — one moment they are in the sprinkler, the next playing with toys,...

What to take from it

Because the sermon refused to rally around a main point, the saint is left with a random collection of his or her favorite points. Weekly, men equipped by the Spirit of God urge the dead to live and the sorely tempted to flee to Christ, to cling to Christ, firing God's very words at their souls to save them. Sermontaries Some Reformed preaching has taken on a professorial character.

Example or evidence

  • It can feel more like reading through the Proverbs than through Paul — golden truths scattered on the floor rather than a sustained, building argument.
  • The sermon should (usually) build around a main idea, and the divisions unveil aspects of that idea, progressing to a climax.
  • Only the most personally appealing pavers stick in the mind.
  • We love to study Scripture (and should) but tend to package what we have learned rather hastily into the weekly sermon.

Details worth keeping

Preach Sermons, Not Commentaries | Desiring God Less fluff. He has indeed, and men preach sermons proclaiming those words. These sermon arrows should be burning, precise, and piercing.

Related coverage

  • Desiringgod: Rigorous exposition isn't at odds with engaging preaching. Pastor John encourages pastors to work for creativity when technical, abstract sermons feel easier. Listen Now
  • Crossway: Learning to preach persuasively takes work. It requires effort—effort beyond exegesis. As a preacher, you need to possess command over not only what you say but how you say it.
  • Desiringgod: Solomon is not an easy book to preach.
  • Crossway: Gunner Gundersen discusses the importance of preaching and practical advice for listeners to pay attention, think deeply, and be receptive to the sermon each Sunday morning.

More context around this story.

Desiringgod iconDesiringgodSep 22, 2026

A Love Song for the People of God

ABSTRACT: The Song of Solomon is not an easy book to preach. It demands careful study, interpretive wisdom, theological balance, and pastoral sensitivity. Yet it richly rewards the effort. The Song gives the church a vision of love that is deeply human and profoundly theological. In the present day — when sex is either

Plan a Sermon Series — on Luke
Asn iconAsnSep 13, 2026

Plan a Sermon Series — on Luke

From Moore College: “Prepare a sermon series! Join us for a day of expert teaching and planning on the book of Luke. Dr Peter Orr is a lecturer at Moore Theological College and is currently finishing a commentary on the book of Luke. Peter will work closely with individuals and staff teams to help them […]

Loading more related stories...

Keep reading in the app

Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.

Open in app