Jewishjournal iconJewishjournalSep 22, 2026 ~7 min source read

A Satirical Reply to 'Habibi City': How One Piece Frames Erasure and Redefinition

Alexandra Ozeri publishes a satirical response to Zaina Arafat’s New York Magazine piece, arguing the original erases Jewish presence and recasts regional identities to suit a political narrative.

NY Mag’s Habibi City

Share this story

Send the public story page.

Useful takeaways from this story.

The response accuses the New York Magazine article of erasing Jewish victims and minimizing antisemitic violence.

Ozeri uses satire to critique selective definitions—especially of SWANA and Zionism—arguing those redefinitions exclude certain groups.

The piece highlights real-world examples cited in the original context: campus rhetoric, street violence in New York, and the aftermath of Oct. 7.

The useful part

By Alexandra Ozeri Published September 22, 2026 [additional-authors] Alexandra Ozeri September 22, 2026 It first hit me in February 2025. We were blithely unaware of, or pleased with, the barrage of antisemitic molotov cocktails, shootings, stabbings, vehicle rammings, arson, terror and mass-murder plots, beatings, death threats, and sexual violence. Later, when I bumped into my farm-to-table pistachio fermenter protesting at a synagogue, near the thoroughly passé metal detectors sponsored by Jews who can't stop complaining about bomb threats, we were just … together.

How it works

  • My fav Columbia psych prof says that's not narcissism, but how genocide works.
  • I'm not trying to show off, but our pro-Hamas encampments responded comparably to MEK, the Red Guards, the Totskyists, the Left Socialist-Revolutionaries and the Komsomol.
  • This wasn't my living room, but it was acceptable, sensually virtuous, to openly hate Jews in the public streets of New York.
  • In 2015, when it was tough to be me, Columbia University was ranked America's most antisemitic university, and my fav professor, PLO spokesman and father-of-modern-terrorism – BFF Rashid Khalidi, harassed...
  • Khalidi supported our vibey crew linked to Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood through AMP —Students for Justice in Palestine, now iconic for celebrating decapitation (when beheading is claimed accidental).

What to take from it

Kind of like "what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas" or "it's not cheating if you're on vacation." Arabization and Islamization can't be colonialism because brown, right? again, I precluded the substantially longer NY history of so many ethnic minorities pressured to be less ethnically identifiable. Probably because these young people were violently killed, suppressed, or imprisoned by the political movements they helped advance.

Example or evidence

  • Vertëbrãe in Arabic means "resistance" and is meant to evoke the mysterious death of Jesus.
  • Suffice it to say, it was terrifying to be a Middle Easterner, or more accurately SWANA.
  • So all these people I demanded aren't SWANA, technically are, but it's … complicated.
  • Of course, I'm referring to the cool kind of colonization, where darling words like "conquest" and "expansion" are used instead.

Details worth keeping

I ran into two friends denying the murder and firebombings of Jews. We finally had the audacity of the Republican party, or my hometown. Just like in the blād, back home, but it was Brooklyn.

Related coverage

  • Observer: Seven stops take in a perfume refill, a handbag appraisal and lemon-pith kosho butter before crossing into Brooklyn for a sorting shift and a night among salvaged heart pine.
  • Grubstreet: Two spots known for their Italian heroes have expanded to dinner.
  • Al Monitor: By Michelle Nichols UNITED NATIONS, Sept 25 (Reuters) - The United Nations wasn't the only New York attraction for visiting world leaders this week – MayorZohran Mamdani emerged as a popular draw for...
  • Jta: Plus, Mamdani visits a Judaica store in Borough Park ahead of Rosh Hashanah. --

More context around this story.

Loading more related stories...

Keep reading in the app

Open the app view to save this story, compare related coverage, and continue from the same source.

Open in app